Forget fancy French pastries and complicated layer cakes, Hoosiers have something better: Indiana Sugar Cream Pie. This ain’t your grandma’s apple pie, oh no. We’re talking creamy magic born from Depression-era grit and a whole lot of love.
Picture this: a velvety filling like a dream, nestled in a buttery crust that practically melts in your mouth. Dashes of cinnamon whisper sweet nothings, while sugar kisses your taste buds with pure Hoosier joy. No fancy ingredients, just pantry staples whipped into pure comfort food heaven.
This ain’t your fancy bake-all-day kinda pie. Whip up the filling faster than you can say “pie,” pour it into a flaky crust (homemade or store-bought, no judgment), and stick it in the oven. That’s it! Now go do your Hoosier thing – watch a basketball game, cheer on the checkered flag, or just kick back on the porch swing. By the time you’re ready for dessert, you’ll have a creamy masterpiece waiting to steal your heart (and maybe your fork).
Indiana Sugar Cream Pie is more than just a treat; it’s a family reunion in a pie pan. Grandmas pass down the recipe, kids lick their sticky fingers with glee, and potlucks wouldn’t be the same without its golden glow. It’s a celebration of simple pleasures, shared laughter, and the magic that happens when cream, sugar, and a whole lot of Hoosier spirit come together.
So, grab your mix, preheat your oven, and channel your inner Hoosier. You might just discover that the best things in life come with a touch of history, a sprinkle of sweetness, and a whole lot of heart. Now go forth and bake, y’all!
Shop Our Baking Mixes
Skip fancy, embrace Hoosier! Ditch the fuss, whip up creamy magic in a buttery crust. Bake Indiana Sugar Cream Pie – faster than you can say “pie”! It’s tradition, smiles, and Hoosier heart on a plate. Grab your mix, y’all! Let’s bake!
