Shop Gourmet Pie Filling Mixes Online.

Find Sugar Cream Pie mix near you.

Check out our variety of gourmet pie filling mixes. Be sure to try our signature flavor, sugar cream.

You deserve homemade!

Upcoming Events

List of Stores

Find Rolling Pin Bakehouse mixes in a store near you. Currently, stores only carry the sugar cream flavor of our pie filling mix.

Baesler's Market

2900 Poplar Street, Terre Haute, IN
get directions →

Baker's Flowers & Gifts

624 Sawyer Rd, Kendallville, IN
get directions →

HomeCraft

400 North Jefferson St, Huntington, IN 46750
get directions →

Indiana Gifts

101 E Main St, Lebanon, IN 46052
get directions →

Mercantile 37

25625 IN 37, Noblesville, IN
get directions →

Miller's Orchard

501 W Randolph St, Nappanee, IN 46550
get directions →

Neighbors Mercantile Co

151 East Market St, Nappanee, IN 46550
get directions →

Niemann Harvest Market

2140 E 116th St, Carmel, IN 46032
get directions →

Rolling Pin Bakehouse

14401 Winters Road, Roanoke, IN
get directions →

Saving Grace Vintage

212 N Main St Suite 2C, Roanoke, IN 46783
get directions →

Shoup's Country Foods

2048 IN-39, Frankfort, IN 46041
get directions →

As seen on…

PBS Logo
WANE-TV channel 15 logo
Whitko Community Schools Logo