Based on 27 reviews
powered by Facebook
The sugar cream pie was the best I've ever had !!!
All the pies for our wedding were beautiful and delicious. I normally don’t like sugar cream, but it was fire! I’ll need to order one for myself sometime, because I only got one bite at the wedding.... Thank you!!!read more
Delicious pies and good prices. We planned on getting a better picture but our family devoured both pies before I had a chance!
Everything we have tried has been GREAT! The cherry pie was awesome and we really like the sweet Amish white bread (great toast, French toast)
Amy Jo Sizemore-Barnes
The sugar cream pie is like no other!
we ordered 2 sugar cream pies for Easter and they were absolutely amazing!! The service for pick up was fantastic as well. We just sat in the car and she brought our pies out to us in the rain and... all.read more
We ordered a variety of items our first time: caramels, cinnamon rolls, coffee cake, sugar cream pie and a buckeye pie. OH. MY. GOSH. Everything was so Heavenly delicious!!!!! I took the buckeye pie... to a ladies gathering and we all didn’t even have words after the first bite because it was so amazing. Same with the cinnamon rolls we all had there. Can’t wait to order again!!! I bought the sugar cream pjs for my husband and he said it was the best one he has ever had!!!! I am going to place another order right now since I’m thinking about it!!! Thank you Rolling Pin Bakehouse!!read more
Kristy Kay McKinney
Delicious homemade pies! My favorite so far is pecan pie
Dawn Betz Moser
Just picked up for the first time and tried the sugar cream pie...awesome!!
Lisa Bowden Clegg
LOVE rolling pin bakehouse!!! The carmels will blow your mind.
I ordered the Sugar Cream pie for the first time during the holidays............. wonderful!! The variety is great and I intend to make future purchases. Natalie is wonderfully accommodating!!!
Dianne Grande Hughes
Oh, my goodness!!! Two apple pies and a cherry pie for two Christmas meals and they were DELICIOUS beyond words!!! Everyone loved them! Thank you, Natalie!!!
Sugar cream pie was AMAZING! Best we've ever had. Thanks, Natalie!
Our young woman's youth group had sugar cream pies tonight for desert...literally melt in your mouth. Thank you for sharing such a sweet talent! I already ordered mine for our Thanksgiving table.
Amazing pecan pie...our family enjoyed one and loved gifting another...highly recommended! 🙂
Gwen Wells Prindle
We had the cinnamon rolls this weekend and we are in cinnamon roll heaven!! Can't wait to try the pies!!
Jenny Knecht Elliott
Great pies! Sugar creme and peach are to die for!!
Carrie Davis Lowe
She made my buckeyes for my wedding and they were awesome!!!
Image Within You
She makes the best peanut butter cookies... ever!
15:44 15 Mar 22
Rolling Pin Bakehouse has the best pies my family has ever had! We have tried the Tollhouse, Sugar Cream, Pecan, Cherry, Apple, and Buckeye so far and each one is amazing! My family now ask for pie instead of cake for their birthdays!
03:24 13 Jan 22
Rolling Pin Bakehouse is the absolute best! Anytime I am visiting Indiana, which is many hours from my home, stopping by to get pie and treats is an absolute must. The toll house cookie pie is my favorite! Excellent in every way.
14:42 11 Jan 22
Delicious homemade pies- sugar cream is a favorite! Great price and customer service. The sugar cream pie kits make a great gift.
18:42 10 Jan 22
There peanut butter pie and sugar cream pie are wonderful! For Christmas we tried the cinnamon rolls and they were amazing. Orders are filled right on time with a big smile! Great bakery and great service! Linda S.
18:03 10 Jan 22
Everything I ordered tasted amazing. My favorites are the sugar cream pie mix and the carmels. Would recommend to everyone.
01:06 25 May 21
My husband’s favorite pie is rhubarb. We are so fortunate to have found this local micro bakery. We pre ordered these pies for my husband’s Birthday and they did not disappoint! My husband said “this is the best rhubarb pie I’ve ever had”!!! My children are not rhubarb pie fans, after trying this one they now love it. The pies were not overly sweet and tart. The baker Natalie’s father grows the rhubarb. The pie crust was excellent. Highly recommend this small local bakery! They even sell Indiana’s famous sugar cream pie. Thank you Rolling Pin Bakehouse!!!
01:10 12 Jan 20
Great pies and goodies just like your mom used to make. Good for birthdays and weddings too. The sugar cream pie will knock your socks off.
19:13 24 Sep 19
The kind of pie that people will put down their work, gather around, and take the time to enjoy with undeniable smiles on their faces.I made sure to save some (not an easy task) for when my brother visited from out of town. Of course, he found it delicious as well.Once I recover from the pie eating contest, I'll be putting in another order. 😁
03:02 09 Jul 13
My kids won a sugar cream pie that Rolling Pin Bakehouse donated to the cake walk at a local festival. It was the best sugar cream pie I've ever had... the crust and filling were perfect. I already ordered another one as my kids didn't think one piece was enough:)
17:23 02 Jan 13
I ordered the caramels and raspberry half moons over Christmas. YUMMY! The caramels were the perfect texture/consistency and got eaten up in a day. My in-laws loved them too. I've tried most of her breads and some of the cookies, have yet to find anything from this bakery that I don't enjoy 🙂
Based on 4 Reviews