NOTE: If ordering for Christmas, please see our select products available for pickup.
- Christmas🎄, More Deliciousness
Caramels
- $9.00
- A rich and chewy candy that will make your mouth water. Includes a 1/2 pound bag of 20 huge individually wrapped caramels. Packaged perfectly for gift giving with a ribbon on top. Gluten-free.
- Add to cart
- Christmas🎄, Pies (9 inch), Baking Mixes, More Deliciousness
Chocolate Cream Pie Filling Mix
- $9.00
- Now you can make a chocolate version of our best selling silky smooth pie on your own. Your friends will be impressed with your “homemade” baking skills. Easy to prepare – just add heavy whipping cream and water. Great for gifts, ships easily, and convenient to have on hand. A gluten-free mix. We also sell unbaked pie crusts – make…
- Add to cart
- More Deliciousness
Cinnamon Swirl Coffee Cake
- $12.00
- A crowd pleaser that you will come back for again and again. 9 x 13 pan.
- Add to cart
- More Deliciousness
Cookbook – Baking With the Pie Lady on 5
- $15.99
- Use this cookbook to learn how to make delicious pies at home. Recipes from excellent pie baker, The Pie Lady on 5. Written to bring out the inner Pie Lady in everyone, she shares all of her tips and tricks for novices and pie-pros alike learned from a lifetime of pie making – and pie eating. Enjoy!
- Buy
- More Deliciousness
Gift Cards
- Order gift cards in any amount.
- Buy
- Christmas🎄, Pies (9 inch), More Deliciousness
Single 9″ Deep Dish Pie Crust
- $2.00
- Purchase a preformed pie crust for baking at home. Pairs perfectly with our Sugar Cream Pie Filling Mix. Can be frozen for up to 4 months.
- Add to cart
- Christmas🎄, Pies (9 inch), Baking Mixes, More Deliciousness
Sugar Cream Pie Filling Mix
- $9.00
- Now you can make our best selling silky smooth pie on your own. Your friends will be impressed with your “homemade” baking skills. Easy to prepare – just add heavy whipping cream and water. Great for gifts, ships easily, and convenient to have on hand. A gluten-free mix. We also sell unbaked pie crusts – make sure to add one…
- Add to cart
