- Pies (9 inch)
Apple Pie
- $12.00
- The classic American pie. Great in the fall or enjoy it year round.
- Select options
- Pies (9 inch)
Apricot Pie (Available May – July)
- $14.00
- Always awesome apricot. Available when apricots are in season - May through July.
- Select options
- Pies (9 inch)
Blueberry Pie
- $14.00
- The very best blueberry pie you will ever taste.
- Select options
- Pies (9 inch)
Blueberry-Peach Pie
- $14.00
- A perfect mix of blueberry and peach.
- Select options
- Pies (9 inch)
Buckeye Pie
- $14.00
- A creamy peanut butter pie topped with delicious chocolate. Made with NO cream cheese.
- Add to cart
- More Deliciousness
Caramels
- $9.00
- A rich and chewy candy that will make your mouth water. Includes a 1/2 pound bag of 20 huge individually wrapped caramels. Packaged perfectly for gift giving with a ribbon on top. Gluten-free.
- Add to cart
- Pies (9 inch)
Cherry Pie
- $14.00
- Tart and sweet. Our cherry pie is made with whole cherries.
- Select options
- Cookies
Chocolate Chip Cookies
- $8.00 per dozen
- A classic staple.
- Add to cart
- Pies (9 inch)
Chocolate Cream Pie
- $14.00
- The chocolate version of our best selling pie - sugar cream. Topped with shaved chocolate pieces.
- Add to cart
- Pies (9 inch), Baking Mixes, More Deliciousness
Chocolate Cream Pie Filling Mix
- $9.00
- Now you can make a chocolate version of our best selling silky smooth pie on your own. Your friends will be impressed with your “homemade” baking skills. Easy to prepare – just add heavy whipping cream and water. Great for gifts, ships easily, and convenient to have on hand. A gluten-free mix. We also sell unbaked pie crusts – make…
- Add to cart
- Cookies
Chocolate Crinkle Cookies
- $8.00 per dozen
- So soft and yummy – you can’t stop at just one!
- Add to cart
- Bread
Cinnamon Rolls
- $2.00 – $15.00
- The perfect amount of brown sugar and cinnamon, topped with smooth buttercream frosting.
- Select options
- More Deliciousness
Cinnamon Swirl Coffee Cake
- $12.00
- A crowd pleaser that you will come back for again and again. 9 x 13 pan.
- Add to cart
- Bread
Crescent Yeast Rolls
- $8.00 per dozen
- These tasty rolls keep their flavor and wonderful texture longer than any other I’ve baked in the past.
- Add to cart
- More Deliciousness
Gift Cards
- Order gift cards in any amount.
- Buy
- Pies (9 inch)
Mint Chocolate Cream Pie
- $14.00
- A timeless combination of chocolate and mint. Topped with Andes Mints.
- Add to cart
- Cookies
Oatmeal Raisin Cookies
- $8.00 per dozen
- You can’t go wrong with oatmeal and raisins.
- Add to cart
- Pies (9 inch)
Peach Pie
- $12.00
- Peach pie perfection.
- Select options
- Pies (9 inch)
Peaches & Cream Pie
- $12.00
- A peachy twist on the sugar cream pie.
- Add to cart
- Cookies
Peanut Butter Cookies
- $8.00 per dozen
- You’ll love the bits of chunky peanut butter.
- Add to cart
- Pies (9 inch)
Pecan Pie
- $12.00
- You’ll love this rich pecan pie. It is one of our best sellers.
- Add to cart
- Pies (9 inch)
Pumpkin Pie
- $12.00
- A holiday tradition that can be enjoyed year-round. This perfect recipe has been handed down through the generations. It was originally sold by my great-grandmother in her small-town pie shop over 50 years ago. Try one and you will see why it has lasted through the ages.
- Add to cart
- Pies (9 inch)
Rhubarb Cream Pie
- $12.00
- One of our most popular pies.
- Add to cart
- Pies (9 inch)
Rhubarb Pie (Available May-June)
- $14.00
- A sweet and tart pie. Available when rhubarb is in season - May through June.
- Select options
End of content
No more pages to load