NOTE: If ordering for Thanksgiving, please see our select products available for pickup.
- Pies (9 inch), Thanksgiving
Apple Pie
- $12.00
- The classic American pie. Great in the fall or enjoy it year round.
- Select options
- Pies (9 inch)
Apricot Pie (Available May – July)
- $14.00
- Always awesome apricot. Available when apricots are in season - May through July.
- Select options
- Pies (9 inch), Thanksgiving
Blueberry Pie
- $14.00
- The very best blueberry pie you will ever taste.
- Select options
- Pies (9 inch)
Blueberry-Peach Pie
- $14.00
- A perfect mix of blueberry and peach.
- Select options
- Pies (9 inch)
Buckeye Pie
- $14.00
- A creamy peanut butter pie topped with delicious chocolate. Made with NO cream cheese.
- Add to cart
- Pies (9 inch), Thanksgiving
Cherry Pie
- $14.00
- Tart and sweet. Our cherry pie is made with whole cherries.
- Select options
- Pies (9 inch)
Chocolate Cream Pie
- $14.00
- The chocolate version of our best selling pie - sugar cream. Topped with shaved chocolate pieces.
- Add to cart
- Baking Mixes, More Deliciousness, Pies (9 inch), Thanksgiving
Chocolate Cream Pie Filling Mix
- $9.00
- Now you can make a chocolate version of our best selling silky smooth pie on your own. Your friends will be impressed with your “homemade” baking skills. Easy to prepare – just add heavy whipping cream and water. Great for gifts, ships easily, and convenient to have on hand. A gluten-free mix. We also sell unbaked pie crusts – make…
- Add to cart
- Pies (9 inch)
Mint Chocolate Cream Pie
- $14.00
- A timeless combination of chocolate and mint. Topped with Andes Mints.
- Add to cart
- Pies (9 inch), Thanksgiving
Peach Pie
- $12.00
- Peach pie perfection.
- Select options
- Pies (9 inch)
Peaches & Cream Pie
- $12.00
- A peachy twist on the sugar cream pie.
- Add to cart
- Pies (9 inch), Thanksgiving
Pecan Pie
- $12.00
- You’ll love this rich pecan pie. It is one of our best sellers.
- Add to cart
- Pies (9 inch), Thanksgiving
Pumpkin Pie
- $12.00
- A holiday tradition that can be enjoyed year-round. This perfect recipe has been handed down through the generations. It was originally sold by my great-grandmother in her small-town pie shop over 50 years ago. Try one and you will see why it has lasted through the ages.
- Add to cart
- Pies (9 inch)
Rhubarb Cream Pie
- $12.00
- One of our most popular pies.
- Add to cart
- Pies (9 inch)
Rhubarb Pie (Available May-June)
- $14.00
- A sweet and tart pie. Available when rhubarb is in season - May through June.
- Select options
- Pies (9 inch), More Deliciousness
Single 9″ Deep Dish Pie Crust
- $2.00
- Purchase a preformed pie crust for baking at home. Pairs perfectly with our Sugar Cream Pie Filling Mix. Can be frozen for up to 4 months.
- Add to cart
- Pies (9 inch)
Strawberry Rhubarb Pie (Available May-June)
- $14.00
- The strawberries balance the tart of the rhubarb for a delightful combination. Available when rhubarb is in season – May through June.
- Select options
- Pies (9 inch), Thanksgiving
Sugar Cream Pie
- $12.00
- Better than any other sugar cream pie you’ve tasted before! Indiana's official state pie and hands down our best seller. This rich and creamy pie will make your taste buds go wild. It was created by my mother years ago and has been a secret family recipe since. If you want to try your hand at making our delicious Sugar…
- Add to cart
- Baking Mixes, More Deliciousness, Pies (9 inch), Thanksgiving
Sugar Cream Pie Filling Mix
- $9.00
- Now you can make our best selling silky smooth pie on your own. Your friends will be impressed with your “homemade” baking skills. Easy to prepare – just add heavy whipping cream and water. Great for gifts, ships easily, and convenient to have on hand. A gluten-free mix. We also sell unbaked pie crusts – make sure to add one…
- Add to cart
- Pies (9 inch), Thanksgiving
Toll House Pie
- $12.00
- This gooey pie is a chocolate chip cookie lover's dream. Top it with ice cream for a decadent treat.
- Add to cart
